I use the one that is Latex base. I know they do make a different one, not sure if that other one is latex based or not, but make sure to get the latex one because that one is for sure fish safe. The other "might" be as well, but I haven't used it so don't take the chance on it.
It also comes in grey and white. If you want a natural grey rock tone like some of the ones I do then get the grey and you can then just shade colors on it once done. If you want to do some other color other than natural grey rock, like say a tank rock or darker rock, then they also make it in white and then you can buy concrete pigments and mix the color you want.
Again, make sure you use GE silicone I* not GE silicone II*, the II* has mildew inhibitors added and is not fish safe. the GE I* (Window/door/attic/basement) is safe.